Legal victory for Sea-Watch: Naples court lifts Sea-Watch 5 detention

By Giulia Messmer2 min read

Photo: Sea-Watch / Copyright

Naples, Italy: The Court of Naples has lifted the 45-day detention of the Sea-Watch 5 and suspended a €7,500 fine. The sanctions were imposed on the allegation that Sea-Watch had failed to communicate with Libyan authorities during a rescue operation in August. Sea-Watch considers the measures unlawful and challenged them in court. In an interim decision, the court followed Sea-Watch’s arguments and suspended both sanctions. The decision removes the blockade that has kept the Sea-Watch 5 from carrying out rescue operations.

The sanctions against Sea-Watch were imposed following a rescue on 13 August, in which the crew of the Sea-Watch 5 rescued six people from the water in international waters. After being ordered to the distant port of Naples by the Italian authorities, the crew was accused upon arrival of having failed to inform the Libyan authorities about the rescue. The ship was subsequently detained.

Sea-Watch welcomes the court’s decision as the latest in a series of successful legal challenges to blockades imposed under the so-called Piantedosi decree, which requires rescue crews to comply with Italian authorities’ instructions to communicate with the so-called Libyan coastguard during rescue operations. Sea-Watch is part of the Justice Fleet, an alliance of civilian search-and-rescue organisations that rejects any attempt to force rescue crews to collaborate with Libyan actors implicated in serious human rights abuses.

Sea-Watch spokesperson Julia Winkler comments:
 

“This decision is a blow to a law that has been illegitimate from the outset. Libya is not a safe place. The so-called Libyan coastguard is part of the violence people are fleeing, not a legitimate rescue actor. The EU’s cooperation with Libya on migration deterrence is a crime against human rights. Full stop.“

Legal victories cannot recover lost rescue time. Since 2023, Italian authorities have detained civilian rescue vessels more than 40 times, costing over 900 operational days. The detention of the Sea-Watch 5 was the eighth such measure imposed in 2026 alone. By the middle of September, civilian rescue vessels had already been prevented from operating for more than 200 days this year.

These are days in which rescue ships were forced to remain in port while people continued to die at sea: in 2026, more than 1,700 people have already died or gone missing on Mediterranean routes. More than 10,000 people have lost their lives in the Mediterranean during Giorgia Meloni’s term of office

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Fields marked with * are mandatory.
Ein Schiff von Sea-Watch im Mittelmeer. Vorne sind einige Wellen zu sehen, und im Hintergrund einige Häuser, da das Boot sich in Küstennähe befindet.

More news

All news

Press Release

First Justice Fleet anniversary: major court wins for the new alliance

One year ago, 13 civilian search and rescue organisations cut all operational contact with the Libyan rescue coordination centre in Tripoli, thereby founding the Justice Fleet Alliance. Since then, their rescue ships were blocked 12 times by the Italian government, amounting to more than 300 days of lost operational time. However, Italian courts confirm the alliance's approach: six times, Italian courts set the ships free again shortly after their detention. Six additional blockades are under judicial procedure at the moment, and the alliance is awaiting their verdicts. While some legal proceedings are still ongoing, none has resulted in a final ruling against Justice Fleet members.

Press Release

2026 is the most violent year in the Mediterranean since 2016

A new report by the civil sea rescue organisation Sea-Watch documents 107 violent incidents by Libyan militias against migrants and refugees, as well as European actors in the Mediterranean since 2016. More than 70 per cent of these incidents of extreme violence, 80 in total, were carried out by the so-called Libyan coastguard. The report is being published shortly before the renewal of Germany’s EUNAVFOR MED IRINI mandate. The current version of the mandate contains no clause excluding the training of the so-called Libyan Coast Guard by the German armed forces (Bundeswehr).

Press Release

Frontex ignores rescue ship - but gives Libyan militia the coordinates of a boat in distress

A Frontex aircraft ignored repeated radio calls from the civilian rescue ship Solidaire, then promptly gave a Libyan militia the coordinates of a boat in distress, facilitating the illegal pullback of the people on board. Sea-Watch’s monitoring aircraft Seabird 2 documented the radio exchange in international waters off Libya, as well as the interception that followed. Frontex radio communications also indicate that Frontex staff share their aircraft positions via Telegram. The incident comes just one day after the European Commission proposed the largest expansion of Frontex to date.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Fields marked with * are mandatory.
Transparente Zivilgesellschaft – We are part of the Transparent Civil Society Initiative: our figures and reports
Sea-Watch e.V. – Civil sea rescue at Europe’s bordersThis site is powered by Netlify